Infertility affects men more than it often looks. Studies of men going through fertility problems find anxiety that peaks around diagnosis and the start of treatment, lasting sadness when treatment doesn’t work, and a strong pull towards keeping feelings contained, often because men believe their job is to stay strong.1 It is also not only her story: a male factor contributes to around half of couples’ fertility problems.2 I know this from both sides. For eight years I was the supportive partner. Then I was diagnosed with male infertility myself.
How men tend to experience infertility
On questionnaires, men often report a little less distress than their partners. That does not mean they feel little. The research suggests men are more likely to cope by trying to solve the problem, making light of it, keeping their feelings in, and seeking less support than their partners do.1 So the strain is there. It just tends to go underground, where it is harder for anyone, including the man himself, to see.
In the couples I work with, it is very often the woman who seems to be riding the emotional rollercoaster while the man is the steady, quieter one. I used to think that meant he was coping better. Now I think it usually means he has found somewhere to put it.
Being “the strong one”
I once spoke with Alice Domar about the mind-body programme she ran for women going through IVF. The men came along for three of the ten sessions, and we talked about how often men don’t share their feelings in this situation. They think one of the two of them has to stay strong, and if their partner is falling apart, it has to be them.
I could relate to that completely. For the eight years my wife was working on her own fertility, I took on the role of the strong one. One of us had to stay hopeful, I thought, for us and for our relationship. So I put my feelings aside and stayed focused on her.
I was wrong. It was not what she wanted. She wanted me on the journey with her, feeling it too, so that she was not the only one going through it.
When the diagnosis is yours
My wake-up call came after eight years. My wife finally had a healthy cycle, after years of healing and natural care, and then we found out I was infertile. The little hope I had been holding onto, the hope my strength was built on, went. I fell apart.
And something unexpected happened. My wife saw me go from being strong to being real. For the first time we were properly in it together, able to hold each other up at different times. It was one of the worst and one of the best things that happened to us. I have written more about that time in coping with a male infertility diagnosis.
He does feel it
One man told me he didn’t have any feelings. If that were true he would be dead! Everyone has feelings. Some of us are just less in touch with them.
If you want proof, watch the same men during a big football match. I remember the 2012 Champions League final: Chelsea a goal down with minutes left, an equaliser, extra time, then a penalty shoot-out they looked certain to lose until they won it. Tears of joy, tears of despair, every emotion in two hours. Infertility is nothing like a game of football, of course. The point is that the feelings are there. They just have somewhere safer to come out.
What helps men
- Put down the strong-one role. Your partner almost certainly wants you with her more than she wants you unshakeable.
- Find the words. I had buried my emotions for so long that I struggled to name them. Writing things down helped me find out what I felt, so that I could then share it. A simple list of feeling words helped too.
- Learn a way of talking about it. I found Marshall Rosenberg’s Nonviolent Communication really useful. Ignore the word “violent” in the title. It is a book about saying what you feel and need without blame.
- Get tested early. Women are often tested first because their cycle gives an outward sign, and their tests are far more invasive. Doing your part sooner is one of the most practical kinds of support you can give.
- Talk to someone. Licensed UK fertility clinics must offer access to counselling, and that offer is for you too, not only your partner.
If you are his partner
Tell him what helps you feel close and united on this journey. Be specific. If losing intimacy has turned sex into one more task alongside the supplements and the appointments, say so, gently, and ask what he is feeling about it too. If he seems untouched by it all, why doesn’t my husband seem upset about infertility? goes into why that so rarely means he doesn’t care.
One thing I am not saying
I am not saying men suffer more than women, or that every quiet partner is secretly falling apart. And being steady for someone you love is not a bad thing in itself. What I am saying is that being strong instead of being real cost us closeness we needed. I believe feeling united helped us through, and that it was part of how we came to conceive naturally. That is my belief about our own story. It is not a promise about anyone else’s.
If you would like some help
The fertility hypnosis programmes include one written specifically for men. This article is also part of Project Baby or Project You, my guide to looking after yourself while trying to conceive.
This is not medical advice. Work of this kind sits alongside your medical treatment, never instead of it.
1. Fisher JRW, Hammarberg K. Psychological and social aspects of infertility in men: an overview of the evidence and implications for psychologically informed clinical care and future research. Asian Journal of Andrology, 2012; 14(1): 121–129.
2. Agarwal A, Mulgund A, Hamada A, Chyatte MR. A unique view on male infertility around the globe. Reproductive Biology and Endocrinology, 2015; 13: 37.